Restock every weekday at Noon EST

Peanut Butter Fan Super Sampler 2.0 (12 Half Pack)

Peanut Butter Fan Super Sampler 2.0 (12 Half Pack)

Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$23
Quantity must be 1 or more

4 Halfsies of our Peanut Butter Buckeyes, PB smiles, and Oreo stuffed PB chocolate chip. 

Customer Reviews

Based on 20 reviews
100%
(20)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
S
Shalyn Tate (Lawrenceville, US)
I didn't get any of'em

My five teens devoured them. I usually heat them up for a few seconds, but they ate them straight from the package.

C
Casey Georgeson (Manhattan Beach, US)
We Can't Stop Eating Them!!!

These are insanely good!! We're obsessed. My husband ate 6 in one night...We have to hide them from our kids. The way the flavors work together is magic. Love love love!

B
B.F.

I am a long-time loyal customer of there's, as I order from them at least three or four times a year. The cookies are always moist soft, and just downright good. This batch was especially good since I love peanut butter and Reese's.

E
Evan Hughes (Seattle, US)
So far so good!

Second batch of cookies / first the sampler then the peanut butter sampler and I couldn’t be happier

C
Carla Jimenez (Los Angeles, US)
INSANE COOKIES!!!

I’m officially a halfsies cookie JUNKIE!! These peanut butter cup stuffed are so good I had to get them as soon as they dropped!!

S
Sarah M (Queens, US)
Perfect!

This was a delicious sampler pack. We loved every single cookie. Hope to see this option again soon!

A
Allyson

These cookies are always amazing; I’ve tried several flavors and this variety pack was my favorite so far.

M
MKB (Chicago, US)
Delicious

These amazing cookies never disappoint 🤍

J
Jeanne Carstensen (Los Angeles, US)
Absolutely Delicious!!!

I cut the halfsies in half and put the out on a tray on the table outside my office at work. They were gone in just a few hours. Everyone raved about how delicious they were. I suggested they might want to .microwave them for a few seconds, but was told they would rather eat them then wait to heat them up.

S
Sarah

Seriously, the best cookies I’ve ever had