Restock every weekday at Noon EDT

Peanut Butter Fan Super Sampler 2.0 (12 Half Pack)

Peanut Butter Fan Super Sampler 2.0 (12 Half Pack)

Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$23
Quantity must be 1 or more

4 Halfsies of our Peanut Butter Buckeyes, PB smiles, and Oreo stuffed PB chocolate chip. 

Customer Reviews

Based on 18 reviews
100%
(18)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
B
B.F.

I am a long-time loyal customer of there's, as I order from them at least three or four times a year. The cookies are always moist soft, and just downright good. This batch was especially good since I love peanut butter and Reese's.

E
Evan Hughes (Seattle, US)
So far so good!

Second batch of cookies / first the sampler then the peanut butter sampler and I couldn’t be happier

C
Carla Jimenez (Los Angeles, US)
INSANE COOKIES!!!

I’m officially a halfsies cookie JUNKIE!! These peanut butter cup stuffed are so good I had to get them as soon as they dropped!!

S
Sarah M (Queens, US)
Perfect!

This was a delicious sampler pack. We loved every single cookie. Hope to see this option again soon!

A
Allyson Hitsman

These cookies are always amazing; I’ve tried several flavors and this variety pack was my favorite so far.

M
Melissa Ben Yoseph (Chicago, US)
Delicious

These amazing cookies never disappoint 🤍

J
Jeanne Carstensen (Los Angeles, US)
Absolutely Delicious!!!

I cut the halfsies in half and put the out on a tray on the table outside my office at work. They were gone in just a few hours. Everyone raved about how delicious they were. I suggested they might want to .microwave them for a few seconds, but was told they would rather eat them then wait to heat them up.

S
Sarah Ward

Seriously, the best cookies I’ve ever had

M
Michelle Bluman (Walkersville, US)
Peanut Butter Amazing-ness

If you love peanut butter, this pack is for you! All of these cookies are amazing! My absolute favorite that Halfsies makes is the peanut butter smiles. Try this one and you’ll be glad you did!

V
Veronica Silver
SO GOOD!

All of these are so delicious! I have a hard deciding which one I want for dessert!