Restock every Monday at Noon EDT

Collection: Today's Starting Lineup

The Halfsies OGs
25 products
  • Halfsies Sampler (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $22
    Sale price
    $22
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $21
    Sale price
    $21
  • Birthday Cake Sugar Cookie with Vanilla Chips (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $21
    Sale price
    $21
  • “I Hate Raisins” Oatmeal Dark Chocolate Chip Cookies (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $21
    Sale price
    $21
  • You Want a Reese's Piece of Me? (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $21
    Sale price
    $21
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $21
    Sale price
    $21
  • S’more Money, S’more Problems (6 Whole Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $13
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Smiles (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Peanut Butter Fan Super Sampler 2.0 (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Blueberry & Cream Cookie (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Fluffernutter (6 Whole Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $13
  • PB Dream (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $22
    Sale price
    $12
  • Bring The HEATh (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Oreo Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookie with Milk Chocolate Chips (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Snickerdoodle Cookie with Caramel Chips (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $21
    Sale price
    $21
  • Banana Walnut Caramel Chip (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Mystery Box 4 12-packs
    Regular price
    $60
    Sale price
    $60
  • Chocolate Cream Pie (6 Whole Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Pistachio Cold Brew Cookies (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Cinnamon Sugared Bananas (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Strawberry Peanut Butter Jelly Time! (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $13
  • Burnin' Love Cookies (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Peanut Butter Banana Bread (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • Orange Ya Glad We Didn't Say Banana? (12 Half Pack)
    Regular price
    $22
    Sale price
    $22