This the best cookie I've ever had, being a Reese's lover. It's not called Masterpieces for nothing, if you're going to make a cookie infused with Reese's pieces, this is how it should be done. These cookies are at the top of the tier.
W
William Fowler (Philadelphia, US)
Peanut Butter Explosion!
I think the title says it all! These are fantastic!
C
Caitlin Hoxsey (Pueblo, US)
Great Cookies
These cookies were amazing! So soft and the flavor was incredible.
S
Sana Nasar (Fremont, US)
Best cookies ever!
I was skeptical buying cookies online. But they are so worth it and tastes just like fresh baked. Highly recommend!
K
Kara Yako (New York, US)
Heavenly
These cookies are absolutely delightful. Warm them up for a bit in the microwave and prepare to indulge! Highly recommend and will keep looking forward to new flavors!
H
Hannah D’Amico (Rochester, US)
100 stars always
Will be a forever customer of Halfsies. These new PB cookies are SO good. Everyone get them.
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device
choosing a selection results in a full page refresh
Knead the Recipe
SO GOOD!
The classic chocolate chip cookies are so delicious, especially after warming them up for 15 seconds in the microwave! You have to try them!
Chocolate Chip Cookie (12 Half Pack)
Ryan D
Cerealsly amazing!
These WERE awesome, emphasis on the were, since I ate them all!
Yabba Dabba Doo Cookies (12 Half Pack)
Andreas Magdeburg
Awesome cookies!!!!!!
Big Apple Sampler (12 Half Pack)
Alexandra P.
So insanely good
I think this flavor is one of my favorites. Bursting with strawberries and the white chocolate gives a creamy texture that just hits every time.
Strawberry Shortcake (12 Half Pack)
Vikki Bennett
ENJOYING THESE
I'M ENJOYING THESE COOKIES LIKE I ALWAYS DO. FLAVORS ARE PERFECT TOGETHER!
These cookies are delicious. The sample pack gives you a chance to try them all and delight in the wonderful flavor samples The may be called”halfsies” but they are filling.
I'm starting to get repetitive with my reviews because they are all sounding the same. While every selection I've made has become a favorite, these cookies have become my absolute favorite. Chocolate lovers, do yourself a favor, get yourself a bag, or 2, or 3.