This the best cookie I've ever had, being a Reese's lover. It's not called Masterpieces for nothing, if you're going to make a cookie infused with Reese's pieces, this is how it should be done. These cookies are at the top of the tier.
W
William R. Fowler (Philadelphia, US)
Peanut Butter Explosion!
I think the title says it all! These are fantastic!
C
Caitlin S (Pueblo, US)
Great Cookies
These cookies were amazing! So soft and the flavor was incredible.
S
Sana N (Fremont, US)
Best cookies ever!
I was skeptical buying cookies online. But they are so worth it and tastes just like fresh baked. Highly recommend!
K
Kara Y. (New York, US)
Heavenly
These cookies are absolutely delightful. Warm them up for a bit in the microwave and prepare to indulge! Highly recommend and will keep looking forward to new flavors!
H
Hannah D’Amico (Rochester, US)
100 stars always
Will be a forever customer of Halfsies. These new PB cookies are SO good. Everyone get them.
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device
choosing a selection results in a full page refresh