Named after the Horse that carried the headless horseman, this cookie is the dark side of our similar Unicorn Cookie. Brown Sugar Base with Peanut Butter Chips, Stuffed with a Peanut Butter Cup, and Rolled in Reese's Pieces.
Best cookies I’ve ever had, especially the Brookies and Daredevils. Packaging was perfect. Will order again.
S
SE (Hyde Park, US)
10 out of 10
K
Kim Vesley (New Windsor, US)
Ok
Wonderful!
S
Shari Segovia (Mooresville, US)
Definitely a lot of peanut butter going on!
These are for the peanut butter lover. I can handle a lot of richness and love sweets. Half was definitely enough of this decadent cookie!
J
Jennifer Cusumano (Newark, US)
Peanut butter lovers dream!
If you love peanut butter this cookie is 100% for you! Absolutely delicious and peanut butter perfection. Another amazing cookie👏👏👏
N
Nichole Miller (Waterloo, US)
Peanut butter fix!!!
Oh, heavenly peanut butter! This cookie will satisfy your peanut butter craving! I will order these again!
L
Lynnette
Omg sooo amazing!!!!
K
Kristen Walker (Ruskin, US)
Daredevil cookies
My husband and I absolutely LOVED this new flavor! Wishing I’d ordered 2 packs! Haha
M
Mary Leap (Leawood, US)
Simply the Best
Better than all the rest. But really, there is something magical about these cookies. Slightly warmed and my heart melts as they melt in my mouth. Don’t hesitate to buy these cookies!
A
Alison Skaleski (Columbus, US)
These cookies were a peanut butter lovers dream! So yummy!!
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device
choosing a selection results in a full page refresh
These cookies are delicious. The sample pack gives you a chance to try them all and delight in the wonderful flavor samples The may be called”halfsies” but they are filling.
I'm starting to get repetitive with my reviews because they are all sounding the same. While every selection I've made has become a favorite, these cookies have become my absolute favorite. Chocolate lovers, do yourself a favor, get yourself a bag, or 2, or 3.
