Cookies available now • Next drop November 12 at Noon EST.

You Want a Reese's Piece of Me? (12 Half Pack)
You Want a Reese's Piece of Me? (12 Half Pack)
You Want a Reese's Piece of Me? (12 Half Pack)

You Want a Reese's Piece of Me? (12 Half Pack)

$21.99
$21.99
Quantity must be 1 or more
  • In every pack: 12 delicious cookie halves.
  • Ships next business day: We ship Monday–Saturday. Delivery time varies with USPS transit.
  • Packed with care: Vacuum-sealed for freshness and carefully packed for the trip.

Heating & storage instructions

Our regular (think chocolate chip) cookie base with Reese's Pieces and our Reese's Peanut Butter Chips.  We couldn't decide if the title should have a question mark or not; because is it really a question?

 

Ingredients: Flour, Cake Flour, Brown Sugar, Granulated Sugar, Peanut Butter Chips (Partially Defatted Peanuts; Sugar; Partially Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil; Corn Syrup Solids; Dextrose;Reduced Minerals, Whey (Milk); Contains 2% Or Less of: Salt; Vanillin, Artificial Flavor; Soy Lecithin), Peanut Butter Candies (SUGAR; PARTIALLY DEFATTED PEANUTS; PARTIALLY HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL (PALM KERNEL AND SOYBEAN OIL); CORN SYRUP; DEXTROSE; CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF: ARTIFICIAL COLOR (YELLOW 5 LAKE; RED 40 LAKE; YELLOW 6 LAKE; BLUE 1 LAKE); CORNSTARCH; SALT; RESINOUS GLAZE; SOY LECITHIN; MODIFIED CORNSTARCH; CARNAUBA WAX; VANILLIN, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR; MILK) Butter, Eggs, Cornstarch, Salt, Baking Soda

 

Allergy statement: Menu items may contain or come into contact with WHEAT, EGGS, PEANUTS, TREE NUTS, SOY, and MILK.

Customer Reviews

Based on 78 reviews
97%
(76)
0%
(0)
1%
(1)
0%
(0)
1%
(1)
100.0
97.5
K
Katherine Altobelli (Ashwaubenon, US)
Better than I even remember!

I was obsessed with these when this company started and Amber Lancaster used to post on them, its been 2 years since I’ve ordered. They are even better than I remember! My kids and I fight over them so I’ve resorted to hiding them in the basement freezer. 10/10!

K
Kelly (Wappingers Falls, US)
For the Peanut Butter loverrrrssss

Best peanut butter cookie that I’ve been looking for my whole life 😍 Definitely heat them up, they become extra gooey and delectable when you put them in the microwave for 30-40 seconds or the oven for a few minutes, even add them as a warm ice cream topping and jeeeeez!

K
Kate Campbell (Milwaukee, US)

Love all the cookies I've had from Halfsies. I eat them warmed up and they are perfection!

J
Jennifer Baxter (Cameron, US)
Stocking up

I always love these cookies. I haven't ordered in a while but when I saw that Dave was taking a break and getting a "real" job, I knew I had to have some for my freezer. Thanks for always putting in the effort and making such great cookies! 😊

L
Lisa Siciliano (Mahwah, US)
Give me more!!

Love them!! Glad I stocked up but they are not going to last long!!

C
Caitlyn (Irvine, US)
Big Reeses fan!

So good especially if you are a Reeses fan! A top peanut butter cookie for me

S
Sarah Paquette (Canastota, US)
Amazing

These cookies are so good! After heating them up, they are so gooey and soft. And so peanut buttery!

S
Shannan C. (Cairo, US)
The BEST

I’m a SUCKER for a good peanut butter cookie even if it gives me wicked heartburn. I will GLADLY suffer for these cookies. I first tried them in the sampler pack and they were easily one of my favorites!

C
Clare M (Santa Fe, US)
Droooooool

Hands down my favorite and I’m not even a big peanut butter person. And I get to think about E.T. Every time I eat one.

B
Brittany (Morristown, US)
to die for

These have been added to my death row meal. They're SO good.