Restock every Monday at Noon EDT

Magic Bar Cookies(12 Half Pack)

Magic Bar Cookies(12 Half Pack)

Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$22.99
Quantity must be 1 or more

Brown sugar base with coconut extract and shredded coconut, dark chocolate chips, almond slivers, and rolled in toffee before baking.

Customer Reviews

Based on 9 reviews
100%
(9)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
T
Tyler R. (Milwaukee, US)
Our Favorite Dessert in Cookie Form

My wife and I love magic cookie bars! After following Halfsies for a while, I thought it was time to test the hype and boy did they deliver. The cookies saw a little bit of heat and turbulence on their journey, but that’s at no fault of Halfsies; the flavor is what mattered to us and it was perfect. I had a hard time not reaching for these every day because they were so good! If you’re on the fence and have read a bunch of reviews like I did, let this be your sign to commit and pull the trigger. You won’t regret it!

c
cindy m (Port Orchard, US)
My new favorite!

Every time I try a new flavor, I have a new favorite flavor! But this time I think it really is my favorite. I've tried the magic bars a couple of times now and they are perfection. Filled with all the good things! Truly delicious!

S
Suzanne (Macon, US)
Absolutely delicious!

This is my second time ordering these cookies - I absolutely love them!

M
M Lewis (Wappingers Falls, US)
Magic Bar Cookies

One of their best cookies yet!!

C
Carmen Millet (Houston, US)
Magic bar goodness

Omg. OMG! I bought the magic bar cookies on a whim and they have changed my life! I’m being dramatic (sort of) but they are absolutely delicious. My partner was skeptical but after one bite, he said “oh wow, that is insane.” Yes, I know! So good and hard to get, so get when the gettin is good.

J
Jennifer D (League City, US)
Best Cookies but even better business

We had a large order that was delayed due to post office. Dave was super quick to resolve. The s’mores and magic bar cookies are 10/10 awesome! We will continue to share Halfsies with everyone.

K
Kathleen Flanagan (Queens, US)
Best yet!

I’ve sampled dozens of Halfsies flavors and these are definitely my new favorite! Love the flavor combo of coconut, chocolate, and toffee 🥰

K
Krista Storlie (Wisconsin Rapids, US)
Magic Bar

These are my favorite cookies so far!

M
Michele

Amazing!!