Ok, we know, it's not a buckeye. But those little treats inspired this monster! Our Peanut Butter Base with Milk and Peanut butter chips- stuffed with an entire reese's peanut butter cup.
These cookies are amazing! Two great flavors combined together. If you love chocolate chip cookies and peanut butter, these are a must have!
E
Elvira
Peanut butter buckeye cookies are by far my favorite cookies! Will be ordering more soon!
J
Joey
Honestly they are too good!
C
Cookie Eater (Chicago, US)
So much peanut buttery goodness
If you love peanut butter and you love cookies, then you’ll love these! 20 seconds in a 1000w microwave does the trick.
A
Ann Mooradian (Severna Park, US)
MMMM SOOO GOOD!
OMG get your hands (mouth) on these cookies asap! They are sooo freaking delicious! Heat from frozen in the air fryer and you won’t be sorry! 🤤 😋
J
Joey
Greatest cookie off all time!
C
Cat Burch (Oneonta, US)
All the peanut butter love
I cannot say enough good things about this cookie. I put this in the microwave for 20 seconds and it was perfect. It was so much peanut butter and chocolately goodness ! The Reese’s cup in the center was perfect
J
Janene Osika (Schenectady, US)
Best Cookiez
Simply the Best…..
J
Julianne Rogers (New York, US)
My favorite cookies of all time
I wish I could find a way to get an alert as soon as these specific cookies are in the lineup. I’m obsessed with them. They stay fresh for days but they rarely last that long in my house. 10/5 stars
