Next Drop Monday 7/22 at Noon EDT

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$22.99
Quantity must be 1 or more

Ok, we know, it's not a buckeye.  But those little treats inspired this monster!   Our Peanut Butter Base with Milk and Peanut butter chips- stuffed with an entire reese's peanut butter cup.

Customer Reviews

Based on 18 reviews
100%
(18)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
W
Wendi Light (Miami, US)
Yuuummm

Never disappoints!! I am hiding them in my freezer. 🤪🤪. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THESE COOKIES, made with love and fun! 🤩

S
SE (Hyde Park, US)
Smooth operator.

This cookie is another great one by halfsies. The cookie is soft and the peanut butter is nice and smooth and not overbearing.

C
Chelsea Zehnacker (Highland, US)
Happy Students and Friends

Shared so many of these delicious cookies with my students and friends. They received rave reviews from everyone. These cookies are well worth the price and definitely deserve the hype. The PB Buckeyes were my personal favorite followed by the s’mores! Love love love them!

K
Kymberlee (Yardley, US)
Substantial!

Like all the peanut butter based cookies from Halfsies, these cookies are substantial and delicious. My son and I cannot get enough of Halfsies!

S
Sondra Lindsey (Harrisburg, US)
Yummy !

Those cookies were just delicious. Will be ordering more. I also got the mixed ones and they were delicious too.

N
Nicole Orefice (Wappingers Falls, US)
Pb buckeyes

Unreal cookie. 10/10

G
Gilbert Chacon (Salt Lake City, US)

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

A
Allison Karis (Whitehall, US)
My favorite!

These are my absolute favorite! A must try ! Perfect combination

B
Brittany Almand (Montgomery, US)
Peanut Butter lovers paradise

So moist, so delicious, yum yum yum

A
Alex (Rockwall, US)
I've never had this flavor and I LOVED IT!

I love to try new fun flavors from Halfsies, you can tell they put so much love in to their cookies!