Free Shipping On Orders Over $100

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$22.99
Quantity must be 1 or more

Ok, we know, it's not a buckeye.  But those little treats inspired this monster!   Our Peanut Butter Base with Milk and Peanut butter chips- stuffed with an entire reese's peanut butter cup.

Customer Reviews

Based on 13 reviews
100%
(13)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
N
Nicole Orefice (Wappingers Falls, US)
Pb buckeyes

Unreal cookie. 10/10

G
Gilbert Chacon (Salt Lake City, US)

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

A
Allison Karis (Whitehall, US)
My favorite!

These are my absolute favorite! A must try ! Perfect combination

B
Brittany Almand (Montgomery, US)
Peanut Butter lovers paradise

So moist, so delicious, yum yum yum

A
Alex (Rockwall, US)
I've never had this flavor and I LOVED IT!

I love to try new fun flavors from Halfsies, you can tell they put so much love in to their cookies!

S
Sean Davis (Ormond Beach, US)
Amazing cookies!

What’s there not to love about the peanut butter cookie and chocolate combination?! The buttercup in the cookie—woo!

S
Samantha Pavlas (Los Angeles, US)
AMAZING!!!

So good and worth every cent! Order them and impress your guests😋

E
Emily Barrett (Carolina, PR)
I did even get a bite, and I bought them!

I brought these to my friends baby shower and as I placed them on the table, walked outside to greet the mother to be, I come back to see the plate is cleared!!! I had 2 others ask me for my recipe 😋
If you want to bring something to a potluck/party, bring these babies

J
Jane Canosa (New Windsor, US)
Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies

Another fantastic cookie from Halfsies Cookie Company! If you love a good peanut butter cookie, this one is worth a try!

K
Kimberly

Excellent