Restock every weekday at Noon EST

Oreo Stuffed Nutella Knockout (12 Half Pack)
Oreo Stuffed Nutella Knockout (12 Half Pack)

Oreo Stuffed Nutella Knockout (12 Half Pack)

$23
$23
Quantity must be 1 or more

Move over Carl's Junior,  Carly Lauren Elias has a new favorite!  Our milk chocolate chip cookie baked with so much Nutella it will bring tears of joy to your eyes AND stuffed with an Oreo!

Carly is a fan of Halfsies and reached out about us creating a flavor for her.  She definitely has a future in creating cookie flavors, because this one is 100/10.  

Customer Reviews

Based on 2 reviews
50%
(1)
0%
(0)
50%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
K
Kaitlynn

Obsessed!! I’ve gifted these cookies to 4 different people this year…. Everyone LOVES them! I will be a loyal customer as long as they are in business!

K
Kelly Smith (Merrimack, US)
Not much Nutella flavor

I thought the cookies were a little underwhelming, but maybe it's my expectations. When I hear Nutella listed as a component I want it to be the star, or at least nominated for best supporting actor. I feel like this was just sort of an extra cast member. I didn't hate the cookie, it was good, I just wouldn't order it again because I think there are other Halfsies I love more.