Restock every Monday at Noon EDT

Fluffernutter (6 Whole Pack)

Fluffernutter (6 Whole Pack)

Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$22.99
Quantity must be 1 or more

Our take on a CLASSIC! Our delicious peanut butter cookie, peanut butter chips, vanilla chips, and stuffed with marshmallows!

Customer Reviews

Based on 8 reviews
75%
(6)
0%
(0)
25%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
M
Madelyn H (Argos, US)
Too good

Ok yum. Definitely recommend warming up a bit. The marshmallow gets all melty and runs through the peanut butter.

A
Amy (Nyack, US)
Wholesies are good too!

Excellent cookies, as always. I would love more of a peanut butter flavor for these, but overall, pretty good New York take on a Boston flavor.

L
Leah (Eureka, US)
Wonderfully delicious!

This was my first pack of whole cookies, and wow... Unless you really want to devour the whole lot in a day – you do you – these are tough to make last! A little on the sweeter side, but they also feel light. Delicious.

M
Michael

Very very good

J
Jason

Another homerun. I don't think these guys know how to make a bad cookie. Thank you!

B
Bonnie Quinlan (Roseland, US)
The best!

these are sooooo delicious. Will be buying more

B
Barbara Kramer (Brooklyn, US)
Fluffernutter

I was a little disappointed. Very little marshmallow.

j
jason vega (Whittier, US)
Nothing wrong

Nothing wrong with the cookies, they were still fresh and consistent just not my pallet. I ordered them because they were the only thing left and I wanted to try, again not bad just not my style