Restock every weekday at Noon EDT

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Regular price
Sold out
Sale price
$23
Quantity must be 1 or more

Ok, we know, it's not a buckeye.  But those little treats inspired this monster!   Our Peanut Butter Base with Milk and Peanut butter chips- stuffed with an entire reese's peanut butter cup.

Customer Reviews

Based on 23 reviews
100%
(23)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
C
Cat Burch (Oneonta, US)
All the peanut butter love

I cannot say enough good things about this cookie. I put this in the microwave for 20 seconds and it was perfect. It was so much peanut butter and chocolately goodness ! The Reese’s cup in the center was perfect

J
Janene Osika (Schenectady, US)
Best Cookiez

Simply the Best…..

J
Julianne Rogers (New York, US)
My favorite cookies of all time

I wish I could find a way to get an alert as soon as these specific cookies are in the lineup. I’m obsessed with them. They stay fresh for days but they rarely last that long in my house. 10/5 stars

N
Nicole Zirngibl (Bloomingdale, US)
Amazing!

The PB Buckeye cookies are my favorite so far!

K
Karen Fry (Arcadia, US)
Worth the wait!

Kept missing these but finally managed to get some. Absolutely worth the wait! Favorite flavor so far!

W
Wendi Light (Miami, US)
Yuuummm

Never disappoints!! I am hiding them in my freezer. 🤪🤪. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THESE COOKIES, made with love and fun! 🤩

s
shannon Eidel (Hyde Park, US)
Smooth operator.

This cookie is another great one by halfsies. The cookie is soft and the peanut butter is nice and smooth and not overbearing.

C
Chelsea Zehnacker (Highland, US)
Happy Students and Friends

Shared so many of these delicious cookies with my students and friends. They received rave reviews from everyone. These cookies are well worth the price and definitely deserve the hype. The PB Buckeyes were my personal favorite followed by the s’mores! Love love love them!

K
Kymberlee Haberman (Yardley, US)
Substantial!

Like all the peanut butter based cookies from Halfsies, these cookies are substantial and delicious. My son and I cannot get enough of Halfsies!

S
Sandy Lindsey (Harrisburg, US)
Yummy !

Those cookies were just delicious. Will be ordering more. I also got the mixed ones and they were delicious too.