Restock every Monday at Noon EDT

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies (12 Half Pack)

Sold out
$22.99
Quantity must be 1 or more
Ok, we know, it's not a buckeye.  But those little treats inspired this monster!   Our Peanut Butter Base with Milk and Peanut butter chips- stuffed with an entire reese's peanut butter cup.

Customer Reviews

Based on 35 reviews
94%
(33)
3%
(1)
3%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
100.0
100.0
C
Carla Jimenez (New York, US)
Cookie Junkie for Halfsies

Came for the KITCHEN SINK, Stayed for the buckeye peanut butter, and FOREVER LOYAL AFTER TRYING THE TOFFEE COFFEE COOKIE!!!

Good god these cookies need to be checked for Crack cuz they are ADDICTING!!!! 1000/10

A
Ann

Best cookies ever! I heat them up in the air fryer straight from frozen. Delicious!

R
Regent Street (Saint Augustine, US)
Halfsies doesn't miss!!!

The Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookies are extremely good; top tier!!!!

Thank You to all at Halfsies Cookie Company!!!

T
Tracy jones (Belfast, US)

Delicious!!!!

M
Michelle B (New Market, US)
Delicious!

These cookies are amazing! Two great flavors combined together. If you love chocolate chip cookies and peanut butter, these are a must have!

E
Elvira

Peanut butter buckeye cookies are by far my favorite cookies! Will be ordering more soon!

J
Joey

Honestly they are too good!

C
Cookie Eater (Chicago, US)
So much peanut buttery goodness

If you love peanut butter and you love cookies, then you’ll love these! 20 seconds in a 1000w microwave does the trick.

A
Ann Mooradian (Severna Park, US)
MMMM SOOO GOOD!

OMG get your hands (mouth) on these cookies asap! They are sooo freaking delicious! Heat from frozen in the air fryer and you won’t be sorry! 🤤 😋

J
Joey

Greatest cookie off all time!

123
Back to Flash Bake Sale Items