This is one of my favorites so far but still trying new ones to see if there’s another that will top it!❤️
K
KC (Queen Creek, US)
Quite delicious!!
M
Mark (Troy, US)
Delicious
I’ve never had a bad cookie from Halfsies. Absolutely delicious if you like Reese’s peanut butter cups.
S
Samantha H (Huntington Beach, US)
New Favorite
Oh my gosh, these cookies are unbelievably good. That Reese’s peanut butter cup in the middle is truly the pièce de résistance. My husband is now also obsessed, will have to stock up every time (so he can get his own!)
K
Karen Pena (Tucson, US)
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Absolutely LOVED these cookies!
M
Marti
Hands down the world's best cookie
M
Megan
Hands down the best cookie I’ve ever had!!!
E
Erin McGuire (Denver, US)
The best!!
These are soooo good! Just get them if they are available. I got 3 flavors for my birthday party and they were all so good! My guests and I especially loved these though!! Can’t go wrong!
K
Kieran Cannistra (Portland, US)
Still smiling
Delicious! This one packs a PUNCH ... an absolute must for peanut-and-chocolate lovers.
